This post contains affiliate links. If you purchase something through the links, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.
Parchment paper is a kitchen staple for baking, roasting, and wrapping food. But cheap parchment paper tears, sticks to your food, or leaves a weird aftertaste.Shopping for kitchen supplies can feel overwhelming. There are dozens of brands on Amazon, and it’s hard to tell which options hold up well and which ones fall short.
We researched dozens of products, reviewing product specifications, design details, and thousands of verified buyer feedback to build our top picks. Shopping for kitchen supplies can feel overwhelming. There are dozens of brands on Amazon, and it’s hard to tell which options hold up well and which ones fall short. We researched dozens of products, reviewing product specifications, design details, and thousands of verified buyer feedback to build our top picks. We do not own every item listed here. Our goal is to help you narrow down your choices before you buy.
1. Reynolds Kitchens Parchment Paper — Best Overall
This is the classic parchment paper everyone knows, and for good reason. It doesn’t stick to cookies or roasted veggies, it doesn’t tear when you line a baking sheet, and it’s oven safe up to 425°F. It’s also available in pre-cut sheets, which makes it even easier to use.
Pros: Non-stick, doesn’t tear, pre-cut sheets available Cons: A little more expensive
2. If You Care Unbleached Parchment Paper — Best Unbleached
If you don’t want the bleached white paper, this unbleached option is great. It’s made from unbleached plant fibers, so there’s no weird chlorine aftertaste, and it still works just as well for baking and roasting. It’s also compostable, which is better for the planet.
Pros: Unbleached, no weird aftertaste, compostable Cons: Brown color, not pure white
3. Amazon Basics Parchment Paper Roll — Best Value
If you bake a lot, this big roll of parchment paper is the best value. It’s 200 feet long, so it lasts for months, and it works just as well as the more expensive brands. It doesn’t stick, it doesn’t tear, and it fits most standard baking sheets.
Pros: Huge roll, cheap, works great Cons: You have to cut it to size yourself
For most people, Reynolds is the best choice because it’s pre-cut and works perfectly. If you want something unbleached and eco-friendly, go with If You Care. If you bake a lot and want the best value, Amazon Basics is a great pick.